Victim Identified in Hollywood Subway Fatal Stabbing

The death of a North Hollywood man is the first on a modern Los Angeles subway, authorities report.

A North Hollywood man who was killed on a Red Line train beneath Hollywood — the first killing on a modern Los Angeles subway — had been involved in a verbal dispute with the suspect before the fatal stabbing, a sheriff's sergeant said today.

The verbal altercation escalated and ended in the death of Jesse Garay, 59, said Sgt. Rich Pena of the Sheriff's Headquarters Bureau.

"The victim, who was in possession of a plastic chain, began to swing the chain at the suspect,'' Pena said. "The suspect hit the victim in the head with a skateboard, then stabbed the victim in the chest, killing him."

Sheriff's deputies said Garay collapsed inside the train compartment and died at the scene.

Surveillance video may show events leading up to the stabbing, which occurred in front of a carload of Metro Rail riders as the subway car sped west under Hollywood Boulevard at 7:30 p.m. Friday. Witnesses, including a Los Angeles Times music reporter, said the skateboarder was attacked by a man who was wielding some type of bicycle chain.

Pena said that based on their investigation, detectives have decided not to release any crime scene videos or surveillance tapes at this point.

The stabbing occurred between the Western and the Vine stations and was the first on the Red Line since it opened in 1993, deputies said.

Times music reporter Todd Martens said he saw the attack.

"The man with a chain started swinging wildly ... he was flailing his chain but it wasn't really hitting the guy," Martens told The Times. "He just seemed crazy.''

A man with two skateboards and a bag pulled out a small knife and stabbed the chain-wielding man in his chest.

The stabber stepped back and said, "Oh, no, why did you make me do
that?'" Martens said.

The wounded man collapsed and began shaking, The Times reported. The train operator momentarily stopped the train, and the stabber slumped to the floor of the train and began asking for help.

"You saw him attack me, right? Please say you did," he asked passengers, according to Martens. In his bag, the stabber, who appeared to be in his 20s, had what looked like a new blue shirt, and two other passengers urged him to change out of his bloodied clothes, according to Martens.

The assailant, described as being of Asian descent with acne scars on his face, put on a new shirt and stuffed the bloody one into his bag, bolting out of the door at the Hollywood/Vine Station.

"There are cameras on the trains," sheriff's Sgt. Harry Drucker said.

"That footage feeds into a hard drive and our homicide detectives will be requesting a download of that video from the Metro people."

Although the incident occurred within Los Angeles city limits, sheriff's deputies patrol Metro Rail facilities and are investigating the case.

They asked anyone any information about the killing to call detectives at (323) 890-5500.

— City News Service

ole blue eyes August 21, 2011 at 06:59 PM
funny how they mention the race of the suspect; but not of the victim, who was the aggressor.
Bret August 22, 2011 at 05:40 AM
Probably because the police are trying to release all the information about the suspect in order to apprehend him. And actually what's it matter what the race was of the man that was killed? They didn't give his height or religion or even his political affiliation, do we need that information, too? If this was a racially charged crime I could understand but wouldn't the police have suggested as much?
John August 22, 2011 at 04:02 PM
You are your silly logic!
Stephen Joyner August 22, 2011 at 08:26 PM
He should have given aid to the guy after stabbing him and called the Sheriff's office. The video on board would have saved him as simply defending himself and possibly others close by. The pasenger on board who advised him to change his shirt could be charged as well. I ride LA's public transportation daily and there is a lot of dangerous people who ride as well despite seeing deputies randomly. In my opinion, I feel the deputies are only there to enforce fare evading and not to protect the public. We are on our own to defend ourselves. Hopefully my opinion is wrong. I'm sure Metro and the LA Sheriff's office will get together to do more to protect us citizens who use the public transportation here in LA.
robbie wilson August 24, 2011 at 11:23 PM
I agree w/ this statement. I refuse to let my son ride without me with him. Loony-tunes ride the train, it feels like tn when we ride it, not the communities. Sad,,,,, feel sorry for the tourist who come across vagrants , drunks and crazies. They won't be back. no $$$


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »